The picture books I used to read with my children were long ago packed away in boxes and consigned to the attic. In a home filled with books, some of the best-loved stories – of bears and gorillas, adventures on the moon and in faraway lands – are no longer on view. Even so, with a little effort, it’s easy to remember them, the books that taught my kids to read, dream, and imagine.

It’s been a long time since I read a picture book, but I recently won an assortment of books in a fundraising raffle that included Peter Sís’s The Wall. It’s a wonderful book and worthy of the many prizes it received, but by no means is it a book exclusively for kids. It tells the story of the author’s upbringing behind the Iron Curtain, in post-war Czechoslovakia, and recounts what it was like to live during the Prague Spring before the Soviet tanks rolled in, crushing everything in their path in 1968. Through a series of intricate drawings, predominantly grey to emphasize the colorlessness of life under a totalitarian regime, Sís conveys brilliantly the constraints, the monotony, and the miserable uniformity, lightened only by occasional glimpses of the symbols of Western freedom: blue jeans, The Beatles, and The Beach Boys.
This novel, by Thomas Mogford, irritated me so frequently that I almost did something I almost never do: toss it aside before completing it. I didn’t, but that says more about my persistence or stubbornness than it does about the book. The problem is the writing: the plodding, lifeless prose, the abundance of clichés, the sheer triteness of it all. OK, I get it. No one picks up a detective novel and expects great writing, right? Well, to use a well-worn phrase that Mr. Mogford would probably be unable to resist, I beg to differ. There are plenty of novelists working in the genre who write beautifully. Benjamin Black, for example, or Susan Hill, or the incomparable John Le Carré. Here, even the plot, the ingredient that rescues most mystery fiction, was dull and predictable. Sleeping Dogs did something so few books do. Something unforgivable. It wasted my time.









