
I never miss a new book by Colm Toibin. I had made a mental note to buy his latest when it was released in the US (January 2023), but I couldn’t resist it when I saw a paperback edition in the bookshop of The Art Gallery of New South Wales in Sydney recently, even though the price of books in Australia seem to me to so high as to constitute a scandal (but that’s a subject for a different day).
A Guest at the Feast is a collection of essays, some more than 20 years old and many first published in The London Review of Books. It could be argued that the publisher is somewhat shamelessly capitalizing on Toibin’s popularity, but no matter. I don’t subscribe to the LRB, so all of the essays here were new to me, and in any case I’d probably buy anything by Toibin that any enterprising publisher chose to put out.
The range of subjects covered in these essays is, at first glance, wide; the abuses perpetrated by Catholic priests in Ireland, the political engagement of the present Pope when he was a priest and bishop in Argentina, the writing of Marilynne Robinson. But the more I read, the more certain themes seemed to recur, especially the intersections of private morality and public and political life. Toibin seems to me to be a writer with a sharp eye for hypocrisy and for the adjustments and accommodations we all make to justify our behavior. But alongside his acuity he is also compassionate and forgiving, and that might explain in some degree the power of his work.
My favorites among these essays were the ones most personal. His account of being treated for cancer is both touching and hilarious and everything he writes about growing up in Wexford is beautiful. But I think the essay on Francis Stuart, an Irish novelist infamous for making broadcasts from Nazi Germany during the war, will stay in my memory the longest, not only for its fascinating account of an extraordinary life but also for its nuanced consideration of the complexities of human behavior.








