A Long Winter

Colm Toibin’s novella, A Long Winter, was first published in 2005 by a small press, then included in a collection, and has now been re-published in hardcover by Picador. Such maneuvers usually make me skeptical. A large publisher, waiting for new work from their famous author, fills the gap by putting out overpriced hardcovers of early or minor work. It is hardly a new ploy, but I need not have worried in this instance. Diehard fans of Toibin’s work, like me, will enjoy A Long Winter, though it never quite reaches the heights of his later novels.

The story is set in a small, isolated village high in the Spanish Pyrenees. This is a place of smallholdings and land owned and worked for generations by poor farmers. A place where everyone knows everyone else’s business and where both friendships and enmities run deep. Miquel lives here with his mother and father. His much loved brother, Jordi, has just left for military service. On a cold, snowy day, Miquel’s mother, after a bitter confrontation with her husband and son, leaves the small farmhouse and never returns.

A Long Winter is a poignant story about loss, loneliness, and love. What is best? To have known love and to endure the pain of losing someone, or to be alone and never experience such loss? Toibin is a brilliantly subtle observer of human behavior and conveys so much feeling with so few words. If he occasionally falls into the trap, as he does here, of trying to do a little too much, it hardly matters because the results are still so powerful and affecting.

Suspicion

Seicho Matsumoto (1909-1992) was one of Japan’s leading and most popular mystery writers. I first read one of his novels (Tokyo Express) about three years ago and remember enjoying it very much, so when I found myself recently at an airport with nothing to read and spotted Suspicion on the shelves I was eager to see what it would be like. It’s an easy read with a straightforward, simple plot focused on a woman facing trial for the murder of her wealthy husband. The reasons for suspecting her are circumstantial and, it should be said, rooted in prejudices about her background and gender. It takes one independent minded and tenacious lawyer to pick apart the case against her and try to save her from conviction and execution. First published more than forty years ago, Suspicion still resonates for modern readers.

Every One Still Here

Every One Still Here is the debut short story collection of an Irish writer called Liadan Ni Chuinn. I became aware of it while reading an interview with the novelist, Ali Smith, who recommended it highly. Smith is a brilliant writer, but our tastes in fiction are clearly very different because I finished the collection of six stories feeling disappointed by it and puzzled by her recommendation. There was something relentlessly grim about the stories and a uniformity of tone and emotional color in the collection as a whole that left me feeling disengaged. What can I say? Smith must have seen something I missed.

Flesh

Flesh, which won the Booker Prize in 2025, tells the story of Istvan. Born in a small town in Hungary, Istvan moves, after a spell in a juvenile prison and some time serving in the Hungarian army, to London where he takes a dead end job as a security guard at a strip club. A moment of selflessness and courage changes the course of his life, taking him into the world of a wealthy businessman. That’s probably enough about the plot because I don’t want to spoil anyone’s enjoyment of an unusual and powerful novel.

The story is a simple enough one. What distinguishes Flesh is its remarkably spare and pared back prose. There is scarcely a wasted word and there is a cool precision to the writing that complements perfectly Istvan’s emotional detachment and the difficulty he has connecting with people and with difficult experiences. Istvan encounters tragedy, success, wealth, and intimacy, yet finds himself towards the end of his life close to the place it all started and without the transformations that he might have expected for all his experience. Flesh is a brilliant accomplishment and well deserves all the accolades it has received.

The Good Liar

A few years have passed since I last read one of Denise Mina’s novels. Her most recent book, The Good Liar, appeared on a number of those “Best Books of The Year” lists that newspapers like to put out every December, so I was pleased when it showed up, neatly wrapped, under the Christmas tree. I devoured it in a few sittings in that quiet spell between Christmas and New Year.

The dilemma at the heart of the book is a simple enough one. To what lengths would you go to avoid admitting you were wrong? Would the fear of shame or the loss of reputation be enough for you to stay silent even if that silence led to a terrible injustice? That’s essentially the conundrum faced by Claudia O’Sheil, the central character in The Good Liar. O’Sheil is a forensic scientist and an expert in blood spatter analysis, a technique that proves central to some gruesome killings among London’s elite.

Mina is a very accomplished storyteller and has achieved the commercial success to prove it. In The Good Liar she is in a comfortable groove and in complete control of the plot and characterization. It’s all carried off with confidence and poise, but I had a sense of the author coasting. There is nothing wrong with that, particularly when the end result is a novel as entertaining as this, but Mina is capable of more.

The Hallmarked Man

It’s that time again. The time when a 900-page novel from Robert Galbraith (aka J. K. Rowling) lands with an audible thud. A novel with a mind-twistingly convoluted plot and scores of characters and with an update on the “will they, won’t they” romance between London’s two best known private detectives, Cormoran and Robin. (Stop reading here if any of this requires explanation).

I suspect Rowling/Galbraith might have a slightly unhealthy interest in secret societies. Previous novels in the Strike series have featured dark dealings in a religious cult and in the more shadowy parts of the online gaming community. (She also seems fascinated by the English upper classes and the clubs where they congregate). For The Hallmarked Man we’re in the company of the Freemasons. A mutilated corpse is found in the vault of a London antiques dealer that specializes in the sale of masonic silverware. Strike’s newest client, a well known chef working in a fancy members’ club, is convinced the body is that of her missing partner. As he starts to investigate the identity of the victim, Strike discovers quickly that it’s not quite as clear as his client thinks and that powerful interests don’t want him interfering.

Loyal readers of the series will recognize all of this. Whether they will welcome it, I’m less sure. For my own part, I started to lose interest half way through and I am finding the meandering, slow advancing, and intricate plots a little bit tiresome. Perhaps someone with influence could have a quiet word with the author and suggest she picks up the pace a little. The Strike franchise, entertaining and successful as it is, might lose even some of its most dedicated followers if she doesn’t.

Eastbound

Most books are published in a relatively small number of standard sizes. While there are good reasons for that, titles published in unusual formats or with distinctive designs have a good chance of standing out among the thousands of similar looking books stocked by the average bookstore. Imaginative publishers know that. Browsing one evening recently in a fairly undistinguished chain bookshop in a Massachusetts mall, my eye was caught by a small, almost square paperback called Eastbound by Maylis de Kerangal. No doubt it was the unusual format and pared down, minimalist design that made me pick it off the shelf.

Eastbound features Aliocha, a young Russian conscript on his way to report for compulsory military service in Siberia. Traveling on the Trans-Siberian Express, Aliocha is so frightened of what lies at the end of the long journey that he is determined to abscond. On the train he meets Helene, a French tourist traveling in first class, and sees an opportunity to escape.

It may seem an implausible tale, but the author (Maylis de Kerangal) creates such an intense and dreamlike atmosphere on board the cramped and claustrophobic train moving relentlessly towards the frozen wastelands of Siberia that it hardly seems to matter. This is a novella about shared humanity, people’s destinies and fates and how they intertwine in the least likely of circumstances. Fevered and almost surreal, Eastbound may be short but it sticks in the memory.

What We Can Know

What can we really know about the past, even in a world in which almost everything – every email, every photograph, every recording – is preserved? What can we ever know about the figures of history, the writers, the artists, the politicians and so on? Do all those biographies that scrutinize every detail of a life ever capture what the living, breathing, and thinking person was truly like ? Do biographers and academics ever get close to the objects of their examination? And what does all that uncovering of the past teach us about the present? Perhaps instead of trawling through archives and reading books and manuscripts, we might learn more about today by imagining a future world and looking back at the present from that vantage point. What we can know is about what we can know. It’s about trying to understand what we can ever really understand, about the past and the present. That is vital because if we can really see clearly, if we can really understand, and if we can really know, from that understanding and knowledge perhaps we might start to value, protect, and preserve what is valuable and meaningful, and stop destroying what really matters before it is too late.

What we can know is is that unusual thing, a novel of ideas. It’s a wonderful accomplishment and to my mind one of the best things McEwan has written for a long time. The story is set in 2119 in Britain, a country which by that time is an archipelago, much of its earlier landmass having been left uninhabitable by rising sea levels. Tom Metcalfe is an academic and his research centers on a poem, written in 2014 and recited at a famous dinner party. No written copy of the poem has ever been found, making it that rarest of things, an unpreserved masterpiece known only by its reputation and by the memories of those who heard it spoken aloud on one occasion more than a century in the past. For Tom the effort to discover the whereabouts of this unread poem is his life’s mission. No spoilers here!

McEwan’s probing intelligence is one of the features I most associate with him and in his least successful novels it can be on full display unleavened by emotional insight. In What we can know the balance is almost perfect. It’s certainly a clever and thought-provoking story, but it also has tenderness, wit, and compassion.

Death and the Gardener

I have the impression that fewer novels are written about fathers and fatherhood than mothers and motherhood. That may simply reflect my reading choices and experience. Anyone who loved their father and lost him to illness is likely to be moved deeply by Death and the Gardener, the most recent novel from the Bulgarian writer (and winner of the International Booker prize in 2023), Georgi Gospodinov.

The book reads like a memoir. The narrator is a celebrated Bulgarian writer and his story is told with the apparently unflinching candor that one normally associates with journals or autobiographies. His account weaves memories of his father with a description of the old man’s illness, treatment, and death, all told in a style marked by simple directness with flashes of real tenderness. It’s one of those books that you find yourself wanting to read more slowly, more carefully, going back over particular sentences and paragraphs to embed them firmly in your memory and experience.

In remembering his father, and telling those remembrances, the narrator creates a eulogy and a memorial that will outlast the father and the son. And Gospodinov, in creating the story, creates a eulogy and memorial for every father that was loved and lost, so that perhaps the sons still living might realize and cherish what they had and what will never return. “We will never be as safe as we once were in our father’s arms“.

Seascraper

Thomas Flett is a shanker. Every morning at low tide he takes his horse and wagon to the beach, scrapes the sand and the shallow waters for shrimp, and delivers his haul for sale in the nearby town. He does it reluctantly and even resentfully, dreaming all the while of the folk music he would like to write and perform. Thomas lives with his mother in a rundown cottage. Money is scarce, so he conceals his ambitions from her, hiding his guitar and everything of his inner life. Work is hard, leaving him little or no time to follow his dreams, until one day, without warning, an American film director shows up scouting for suitable locations for his new project.

Disappointed and disillusioned young men, tied to labors they loathe, tethered by poverty, and dreaming of other lives are something of a literary staple. Think of Thomas Hardy, for example. Seascraper is firmly within that tradition. That in no way is intended to diminish Benjamin Wood’s achievement here. His tale is a memorable and poignant one, and he writes with great feeling for the frustrations of daily life and especially of thwarted ambition. In spite of that, Seascraper for me didn’t quite come off. It’s filled with atmosphere and the character of Thomas is written with subtlety and insight, but minor characters feel sketched rather than fully drawn. Nevertheless, this is a fine novel and one I’m pleased to have read.